Water heater replacement and installation in York, PA

When a water heater is leaking from the tank or past repairing, Anytime Heating & Cooling replaces it with a new gas, electric, propane or tankless unit sized for your household. We serve greater York, PA, and estimates are free.

4.9 from 108 Google reviews · Answered 24/7

Replaced our water heater within 24 hours of our initial call. Very responsive, knowledgeable, and quick workers. Highly recommend!”

Abbey H. · Water heater replacement · April 2022

Rheem installation specialists. Service for every major brand.

  • Carrier
  • Lennox
  • Goodman
  • Daikin
  • Mitsubishi Electric

Choosing a new water heater

Tank or tankless
A tank costs less upfront. Tankless never runs out and lasts longer, but costs more and may need gas or venting upgrades.
Fuel
Gas and propane heat faster and usually cost less to run. Electric needs no venting.
Size
Tanks are sized by gallons and first-hour rating, tankless by flow rate. Both should match how much hot water your household uses at once.
Efficiency
Water heaters are rated by UEF. A higher number means less energy to heat the same water.

How a water heater replacement works

  1. Estimate

    We look at your current heater, your household’s hot water use and the space, then quote options.

  2. Install

    We drain and remove the old heater, set the new one, connect the water, gas or power and venting, and add any parts code requires.

  3. Test

    We fill it, fire it up, check for leaks and proper venting, set the temperature, and haul the old one away.

What customers say about our water heater replacement

4.9 from 108 Google reviews
  • We noticed our gas water heater was leaking. Reached out to Brennan and he got us in his schedule right away. They were in and out in less than 2 hours. The new water heater looks better than the one they replaced.”

    Kristal R.Water heater replacement · September 2026
  • We’ve used this company twice! Once for a AC repair and another time for replacing a broken hot water heater. Both times the technician showed up in a timely manner and was super professional.”

    Kelsey L.Water heater replacement · December 2025

FAQ

Water heater replacement questions

Browse all our FAQs

How long does it take to replace a water heater?

A straight swap of a standard tank usually takes a few hours. Moving to a different type, such as switching to tankless, can take longer because of gas, venting or electrical changes.

What size water heater do I need?

It depends on how many people live in the home and how much hot water you use at once. Many homes use a 40 or 50 gallon tank. We will size it to your household.

Are water heater estimates free?

Yes. Estimates are free. Call (717) 758-8664 or request one online.

Call nowFree estimate

Free estimate

Tell us what’s going on and we’ll call you back to set a time.

What do you need?
Is it not working right now?

Rather talk it through? Call (717) 758-8664